Herlihy Moving & Storage INC

★ 4.0· 111 reviews · Chillicothe, OH

✓ Licensed (USDOT 183389) ✓ Insured · $750K liability ✓ Cargo covered Active carrier

USDOT number: 183389 ↗
MC number: MC129321 ↗
Phone: (740) 775-6683
Fleet: 2 trucks · 2 drivers
Safety (FMCSA): 0 inspections · 5 crashes
Service area: Interstate moves
Location: 747 MARIETTA ROAD, Chillicothe, OH 45601
FMCSA registration updated: Apr 2026

Contact

Email: [email protected]
Mobile: (740) 253-2203
Website: herlihymoving.com

MoversSelf Storage

View on Google (4.1, 99) View on Yelp (2.8, 12)

Location

View larger map →

Rating trend by year

Share of 1–5★ reviews per year, Google + Yelp combined (99 dated reviews)

1★

2011

1★

2015

4.3★

2016

5★

2017

4★

2018

3.8★

2019

4.5★

2020

5★

2021

4.9★

2022

3.8★

2023

4.2★

2024

3.5★

2025

4.5★

2026

5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★

Rating breakdown

4.0

111 reviews total

Star-by-star breakdown above is based on the 99 reviews we've captured the full text of so far — out of 111 total reviews across Google & Yelp.

Customer reviews (111)

Sort by

★★★★★★★★★★ Google

Intitial left a 3 star review, the 3 stars was because I wasn't able to purchase online. I received a call back though and customer service was great. They was very helpful.

John Stanley · Jun 2026

★★★★★★★★★★ Google

Justin, Roeshawn, and Mason were awesome! They were quick and efficient with little oversize needed. Hopefully this is the last move personally, but if not, they will be my first call. Pricing was reasonable.

Amy Nelson · Apr 2026

★★★★★★★★★★ Google

I can’t say enough about the customer service I received. From the first call to the last call. I am a tanning salon owner and I needed tanning beds picked up and delivered to me. The movers were great to talk to and funny. They were very professional and very careful with the beds. Highly recommend...

Alexis McCann · Feb 2026

★★★★★★★★★★ Google

Herlihy Moving helped us pack up large items at our condo and move them across town to our new home. Mason, Nehemiah, and Zach were all very professional, courteous, and careful throughout the process. They did everything we asked of them (including wearing shoe covers in the house), reassembled any...

Max Litter · Jan 2026

★★★★★★★★★★ Google

Really good place to get a storage unit

Celestia Sykes · Dec 2024

★★★★★★★★★★ Google

I have never experienced such wonderful customer service with a moving company. Moving is so stressful but there was a gal working, I think her name was Kylie and she relieved so much of my stress just by knowing her stuff and she also had me cracking up laughing. Like I had such a good experience I...

Pacetrain · Apr 2024

We read this company's 9 lowest-rated reviews and sorted what they describe, unverified, as written by the reviewers. A type is listed once two or more reviewers describe it, and a review that describes two problems is counted in both rows. Quotes are the reviewers' own words.

Damaged or lost belongingsItems broken, lost or missing during the move

4 reviews · latest 2026

“Almost every single piece of furniture ended up with some kind of damage, from scratches and dents to broken drawers and shelves.” 2★ · Google · Jun 2026 · Anne B · Read the review →

“some of our furniture was badly scratched. Side rails to a queen bed are missing and they can't find them. Good China was missing.” 1★ · Google · Nov 2015 · Damaris Mosley · Read the review →

Belongings held for extra paymentCrew refused to unload or deliver until paid more

2 reviews · latest 2025

“when they came time to deliver it they would not until I paid another 3000$.” 1★ · Google · Mar 2025 · Cookie Lewis · Read the review →

“Joe HERLIHY The president of the company personally called myself and my mother telling us,(after we had already left the state and moved to Florida) we wouldn't get any of our belongings if she didn't sign the inventory” 1★ · Google · Aug 2024 · Angela Strausbaugh · Read the review →

These are customers' accounts, quoted as written. Problem types and sums are our reading of each review. We do not verify individual claims, and the company may dispute them. Counts cover the 9 low-rated reviews we read, not every review on Google or Yelp. Bars compare the types with each other.

Considering other options? Compare movers near you →